those are both great tires for your area ,tire rack has good reviews you really want to focus on the reviews that people put 30k or more miles but I bet they are neck and neck with quality , I know both brands are made at different plants so I would go for made in USA if either is,example my goodyear weather ready is made in US or Chile it probably doesnt matter but I was surprised when I got them from tire rack and they were Chlle made in 215/65/16 and the 2nd 4 from PEPBOYS but I try to buy USA if I can is what i'm getting at ,I hope the soybean oil is not going to be a mistake $1,200 in tires on both CRV's time will tell