Silly question, but did you replace with the same part number? From my experiences Honda engine are abit finicky with the type of sensor you put in them. I use to have a V6 accord, replacing the bank 1 O2 sensor, throw a check engine light, same NGK brand just a different part number, replaced with the exact from the dealer CEL goes away. I believe this is the correct part number for it.
HondaPartsNow.com offers the lowest price and fast delivery for genuine 2008 Honda CR-V 5 Door EX-L (2WD NAVIGATION) KA 5AT Exhaust Pipe - Muffler.
www.hondapartsnow.com