I went with the OEM after looking into both Yakima and Thule. The cost for parts was virtually identical for all 3. The biggest advantage of Yak/Thule is that you clamp them on yourself and don't have to worry about installation. Unless you have specific roof equipment that needs spacing different from the OEM set-up, they all appear to be comparable in my view.Watching as I'm trying to decide this too
With the OEM, I decided to do the install myself, which was quite easy and only took about 30 minutes.