[uskallen]

After experiencing intermittent starting (times where I would hear a click from the front end but starter would not engage) and reading this thread and others, I had my starter replaced yesterday. I found a brand new one on amazon for about $85 and paid a nearby shop $110 to replace. I had called the shop I typically use, but they only use OEM Honda parts and they quoted me almost $800. I kept the old starter so I can take to Autozone to have tested and I can possibly repair or replace it in case I ever have to do this again. I'm also looking into the popular upgrade to the 24F size battery to minimize those chances. After reading up on this issue, it sounds like it is caused mostly by using the small 51R battery with low CCA and the weak charging system that doesn't recharge the battery quickly, which is exacerbated by short trips. These factors all contribute to premature wear on the starter and solenoid. I will make sure to drive with my headlights on all the time regardless of whether I upgrade the battery.