Very true. The lights from that Prime retailer looked sketchy. I ordered a replacement assembly from Rockauto. I'm hoping the Dorman 923-131 light works for a few years.
I could replace the bad SMT LED, but equivalent parts would need to be ordered from an electronics distributor. The other LEDs in the string are 12 years old, so all 4 should be replaced. If this was a project car, it might be worth the effort.
Short-term cheat: A solder blob was added across the dead LED. Now 3 LEDs light up slightly brighter. This cheat won't last long, but it should survive until the new light assembly arrives. Don't try this at home ;-)