Honda CR-V Owners Club Forums banner
Status
Not open for further replies.

Went to the Dark Side (Traded my CR-V for a Tucson)

24K views 21 replies 17 participants last post by  mrtn  
#1 ·
Well about a month ago I traded my blue 2017 CR-V for a beautiful black 2023 Hyundai Tucson Limited and I figured I'd share some of my thoughts before I bid the Honda forum adieu. In case you are wondering, the other vehicles in contention were a Kia Sportage and more distantly a Nissan Rogue. The 2023 CR-V and RAV4 were out of contention due to low inventory and horrendous dealer markups.

Let me preface this by saying I am under no delusion that Hyundai is a luxury marque, but compared to my CR-V EX-L this car certainly feels like a luxury vehicle. The Tucson is very sharp looking and the cabin looks and feels so much more sleek and expensive. The Tucson is equipped with much better driver assistance and infotainment technology as well as creature comforts like heated/cooled front seats, heated steering wheel, and heated rear seats. I love the fully digital instrument panel as well as the backup camera/360 camera. The navigation works great and the driver assistance technologies are quite a bit more advanced than that of the CR-V.

As far as the driving characteristics are concerned, the Tucson drives so much better than the CR-V. I'm told that Hyundai hired engineers from the German automakers a few years ago and if they did it certainly shows. Everything is a lot more responsive and precise. The 2.5L engine and 8-speed conventional automatic transmission are head and shoulders above the 1.5L engine and the CVT in the CR-V. The car rides and handles so much better and the cabin is a lot quieter. Even the AWD system feels a lot more robust. All in all Hyundai did a great job designing this Tucson. I am very pleased with the vehicle and wouldn't hesitate to recommend it over a CR-V. For what it's worth, even in this horrible market I was able to get the Tucson for $1000 under sticker. It also doesn't hurt that the Tucson includes a 10 year/100,000 mile powertrain warranty, 5 year/60,000 mile bumper to bumper, as well as 3 years complimentary maintenance.

Are there a few drawbacks compared to the CR-V? The CR-V had a more comfortable driver seat but I remedied this with a foam cushion purchased from Amazon. The CR-V also had a better sound system and so far I'm averaging about 4 mpg lower fuel economy with the Tucson however I only have about 600 miles on the Tucson so far (mostly city) so I expect to see some improvement as the engine breaks in. Admittedly I haven't had any experience with the 2023 CR-V, but if you're looking to replace your Gen 5 CR-V, you're doing yourself a disservice if you don't at least take a Tucson for a test drive.
 
#2 ·
Immediate question comes to mind. Did they fix that ignition flaw that makes their vehicles easy to steal? Just came back this morning driving the 2018 crv and thought that the cvt wasnt bad (read stories about Nissan cvt). Was thinking that I don't have to change fluidfor the cvt, a plus as compared to the conventional auto. I used to own a 2002 Sonata so I am not really impressed with KIA Hyundai. It's so true about uou only have 1 chance to impress.
 
#3 ·
If you don't change the CR-V CVT fluid every 25,000 to 30,000 miles - it will not last. The lubricant is almost gone at 40,000 miles. There have been CR-V and Accord CVT failures due to not changing the fluids. It is simple - open the the fill test and the drain, put back the drain plugs when it stops flowing - add 4 quarts into the plug in the engine compartment - open the fill test and when the excess flows out put it back.
$40 vs $4000 for a new CVT.

It could be worse - the Mercedes its $400 fluids for the CVT fluids.
 
#4 ·
I also think anytime you make a 6 +/- year jump in model years, it’s going to seem like a pretty dramatic improvement in creature comforts and tech. e.g., My 2020 CRV is a major improvement vs my 2012 CRV, like two different vehicles even at the same trim level. I got rid of the 2012 after 1 year, but am very satisfied with the 2020.
 
#13 ·
I get a chuckle every time I see the Santa Cruz. I don't think they could make it look like an older Ridgeline if they tried.

Never heard of a CVA. CVT does have transmission fluid.
I just went through the maintenance schedule for the 2023 sport touring. There is no mention of CVT fluids needed to be changed. The transmission is one of the generators. Please explain to me what I am missing because clearly I am missing something. If the other cars have a mechanical CVT that makes sense but that doesn't change that I will not have a mechanical transmission and will not have to deal with fluids.
 
Save
#7 ·
There's a reason Hyundai can't command any sort of "horrendous" dealer markup. Also I don't think paying MSRP for a car in todays climate is all that bad, especially given I got 17,000 for my old Civic with 80,000 miles on it, I only paid 24,000 Brand new, I picked up my 2023 CR-V sport touring and i'm amazed at the quiet, smoothness and fuel economy is amazing. Basically everything my 2017 Honda Civic Touring didn't do well, this does leaps and bounds better. Never would a Hyundai be on my radar. Remember you do get what you pay for. I can't get over how the Adaptive cruise now feels like it's a human modulating brakes and accelerator, even the rain sensing wipers which used to be psychotic at best on the civic work exactly as I would think they should. Personally I feel you made a mistake. But to each their own. Hyundai/Kia reached out to the germans for design, not engineering, that's why the optima sold so well because it finally didn't look like a Hyundai/Kia. Hyundai needs to focus on reliability before they make all these new models that have sub par engines and terrible electronics reliability. The failure rate of engines with Hyundai/Kia is still insane. Good thing they do come with a 100K warranty because you will definitely be using it. Also, when you do decide to get rid of that Hyundai, that's where you're going to see you get what you pay for, it won't hold its resale value at all. The fact that you have no experience of the 2023 CR-V I suggest you do not drive one, you'll absolutely regret buying that Hyundai.
 
#17 · (Edited)
I agree that when you make a 6 year jump in models, you are going to see a big difference in the car.

My 2023 CRV Sport Touring feels so much larger, heavier and more substantial than my 2015. The ride and handling is so much better also.
It's also light years ahead as far as tech... I was at the drive through window at the Burger Doodle in my new car and it "corrected" my order. It said, "I don't think so! .. he will have the salad and a water". I'm looking in the manual for how to disable the "old married couple" feature.

With each car in the segment, there are certain trade-offs. The CRV has good interior space, the Forester has great AWD, the Mazda is fun to drive, Rav4 gets the best gas mileage, etc.
I wanted good space, better gas milage - which I'm getting with the hybrid, and resale value. The '23 Sport Touring was the right combo for me - but I understand someone making a different choice for sure.

Congrats on your new ride. Come back after a year and let us know what your thoughts are - I would be curious.
 
#19 ·
Now I have a A12 code on my dash and I've ignored it for like 5k miles. I'm same with Woodburn in that I didn't think CVT needs fluid change b/c it is belt driven (?). In any case, isn't the A12 for transmission fluid change? :) I'm confused.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.