I apologize. A comment that I think to be funny can come across as sarcastic. After reading this thread I thought such strong opinions on something as pedestrian as a crush washer was humorous, which is why I made the comment that I did.
Above is the crush washer I took off of the drain plug when I changed the oil. The ridge on the right side is a bit wider than the ridge on the left side. If the washer is not exactly the in the same position when reinstalled will it seal properly? What if I did not notice and put the ridge under the head of the drain plug? Would it seal properly? Now that it is crushed, to what torque is it tightened? If all of the microscopic hills and valleys on the drain plug, oil pan, and crush washer don't line up exactly, will it reseal properly? I don't know the answer to any of those questions. They are all irrelevant if I put on a new crush washer and for $0.35 it is worth it to me not to consider any of them.
Could a new crush washer leak? Absolutely. But which is less likely to leak, a new one or an old one? For me I think the new washer is less likely to leak. That is just my opinion, and whatever anyone decides is right for their car is just as valid for them as what I think is right for mine.
And off topic, it is insane what the dealership charged. And even more insane is that I never checked the oil level until after driving more that 3,000 miles over the winter. I mean, why check the oil, it is a Honda, right? Well, I was proven wrong again. The oil was way high, which I never expected. I took out 32 ounces of oil just to bring the oil level down to the highest mark on the dipstick. So did the dealership overfill the crankcase or do I have the infamous oil dilution problem? I went back to the dealership and they said that they never heard of the problem. For now I know two things, the proper amount of oil was used to refill the crankcase, and I will not go back to that dealership for service.